Introduction
The eyebrows are one of the most prominent characteristics of your face. They frame your eyes, define your expression, and enhance your overall beauty. An eyebrow pencil becomes a crucial tool in achieving well-groomed brows, though it is not part of the Essential Makeup Kit, but offers the means to fill, shape, and define, ultimately accentuating your facial features for a polished and put-together look. If you’d like to use it, then you need to know how to choose eyebrow pencil color for your brows. If you pick a shade that is too dark, too light, or too warm, you might end up looking unnatural, harsh, or washed out.
In this article, we will guide you through the process of finding the perfect eyebrow pencil color for your brows, based on your hair color, skin tone, and skin undertone.
Factors to consider while choosing eyebrow pencil color
You might have seen already that there are different colors available in the market for eyebrow pencils, how do you decide which one is right for you? There are three main factors that you need to consider while choosing eyebrow pencil color:
1 – Natural Eyebrow Color or Hair Color
The first factor in choosing the eyebrow pencil color is your natural eyebrow color or hair color. Generally speaking, you want to match your eyebrow pencil color to your natural eyebrow color or hair color, as closely as possible. This will create the most natural and harmonious look for your face. However, there are some exceptions to this rule.
For example, if you have very sparse or light eyebrows, you might want to go one shade darker than your natural eyebrow color or hair color, to create more definition and contrast. If you have very thick or dark eyebrows, you might want to go one shade lighter than your natural eyebrow color or hair color, to create more softness and balance.
2 – Skin Tone
The second factor to choose the eyebrow pencil color is your skin tone. Your skin tone refers to how light or dark your skin is, regardless of its undertone. Your skin tone can range from fair to dark, depending on how much melanin (the pigment that gives color to your skin) you have in your skin cells. So, your skin tone can affect how your eyebrow pencil color looks on you, as it can either complement or clash with your skin color.
For example, if you have a fair skin tone, you might want to avoid using a very dark or very light eyebrow pencil color, as it can make your brows look too harsh or too invisible. Instead, opt for a medium or light brown shade that matches your hair color. If you have a dark skin tone, you might want to avoid using a very light or very warm eyebrow pencil color, as it can make your brows look too ashy or too orange. Instead, opt for a dark or cool brown shade that matches your hair color.
3 – Skin Undertone
The third factor to choose the eyebrow pencil color, is your skin’s undertone. Your skin undertone refers to the subtle hue that shows through your skin, and it can be warm, cool, or neutral. Your skin’s undertone is determined by the amount and type of hemoglobin (the protein that carries oxygen in your blood) and carotene (the pigment that gives color to fruits and vegetables) in your skin cells.
Examine the veins on your wrist to figure out your undertone. If they appear yellowish, you have a warm undertone. If they appear bluish or purplish, you have a cool undertone; and if they appear neither yellow nor blue, you have a neutral undertone. Your skin undertone can affect how your eyebrow pencil color looks on you, as it can either enhance or dull your natural coloring.
For example, if you have a warm undertone, you might want to avoid using a very cool or very gray eyebrow pencil color, as it can make your brows look too dull or too blue. Instead, opt for a warm or neutral brown shade that matches your hair color. If you have a cool undertone, you might want to avoid using a very warm or very red eyebrow pencil color, as it can make your brows look too bright or too pink. Instead, opt for a cool or neutral brown shade that matches your hair color.
How To Choose The Right Eyebrow Pencil Color
To make things easier for you, we have created a chart below. It shows you the best eyebrow pencil color for your brows, based on your hair color, skin tone, and skin undertone. You can use this chart as a reference. But remember that these are only general guidelines, and you might need to adjust the shade depending on your personal preference and the look you want to achieve.
1 – For Black Hair Color
| Skin Tone | Skin Undertone | Eyebrow Pencil Color |
|---|---|---|
| Fair | Warm / Cool / Neutral | Taupe |
| Medium / Dark | Warm / Cool / Neutral | Black / Gray |
2 – For Brown Hair Color
| Skin Tone | Skin Undertone | Eyebrow Pencil Color |
|---|---|---|
| Fair / Medium | Warm | Warm Brown |
| Fair / Medium | Cool | Cool Brown |
| Fair / Medium | Neutral | Neutral Brown |
| Dark | Warm / Cool / Neutral | Dark Brown |
3 – For Blonde Hair Color
| Skin Tone | Skin Undertone | Eyebrow Pencil Color |
|---|---|---|
| Fair / Medium | Warm / Neutral | Blonde |
| Fair / Medium | Cool | Taupe |
| Dark | Warm / Cool / Neutral | Light Brown |
4 – For Red Hair Color
| Skin Tone | Skin Undertone | Eyebrow Pencil Color |
|---|---|---|
| Fair / Medium | Warm / Cool / Neutral | Auburn |
| Dark | Warm / Cool / Neutral | Dark Auburn |
5 – For Gray Hair Color
| Skin Tone | Skin Undertone | Eyebrow Pencil Color |
|---|---|---|
| Fair / Medium | Warm / Neutral | Taupe |
| Fair / Medium | Cool | Gray |
| Dark | Warm / Cool / Neutral | Gray |
What are the colors available for eyebrow Pencils?
Eyebrow pencils come in a variety of colors, ranging from black to blonde, and everything in between. Some of the most common colors are listed below with recommended products available in India. Before you purchase, please read the full article including the chart, where recommended eyebrow pencil colors are mentioned based on Hair Color, Skin Tone, and Skin Undertone.
🔗 Affiliate Disclaimer: This article may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
🛒 Shop worry-free. All the shopping links are 100% Safe and Secured, from top e-commerce sites.
Shopping Instruction
- Use the merchant website in the browser, instead of a mobile app, when shopping from the provided links.
- Click any link when ready to shop, add items to your cart, and complete the purchase within 24 hours.
- Your support will be highly appreciated and it will help us to run our website with more quality content.
1 – Black
This is the darkest shade of eyebrow pencil, and it is suitable for people with jet-black hair and very dark skin tones. However, be careful not to use a black pencil that is too harsh or matte, as it can make your brows look unnatural and drawn on. Instead, opt for a black pencil that has a soft texture and a slight sheen, to mimic the natural shine of your hair. For the safer side, you can also consider Dark Gray, instead of Black.
FEATURED
COLORESSENCE Expert Brow Pencil-2 in 1 (Black)
Description / Features
- The 2-in-one Eyebrow pencil serves as both a precise angular tip pencil for filling brows and a professional shaping spoolie for a complete eyebrow grooming experience.
- This eyebrow pencil features a professional spoolie that ensures precise shaping and sets the brows, providing a long-lasting matte finish.
- The Expert Eyebrow Pencil by Coloressence offers a waterproof and smudge-proof formula, ensuring that your perfectly shaped brows stay intact throughout the day.
2 – Brown
This is the most versatile shade of eyebrow pencil, and it can suit many different hair colors and skin tones. However, not all browns are created equal. Depending on your hair color and skin undertone, you might need a warm brown, a cool brown, or a neutral brown pencil.
For example, if you have warm brown hair and a warm undertone, you might want to use a warm brown pencil that has some red or orange tones in it. If you have cool brown hair and a cool undertone, you might want to use a cool brown pencil that has some ash or gray tones in it. If you have neutral brown hair and a neutral undertone, you might want to use a neutral brown pencil that has a balance of warm and cool tones in it.
FEATURED
MAYBELLINE NEW YORK Define & Blend Brow Pencil With Spoolie (Natural Brown)
Description / Features
- Maybelline New York’s Define & Blend Brow Pencil provides full and defined brows with a unique slim angled tip for natural-looking strokes.
- This brow pencil features a convenient retractable design and includes a brush, allowing for easy application and blending.
- The pencil comes in a natural brown shade, ensuring a subtle and authentic look for your eyebrows.
3 – Taupe
This is a light brown shade that has some gray tones in it. It is ideal for people with light brown, dark blonde, or gray hair, and fair to medium skin tones. Taupe can also work for people with black hair and fair skin, as long as they use a light hand and blend well. Taupe can create a soft and natural look for your brows, without making them too dark or too light.
FEATURED
SUGAR Cosmetics Arch Arrival Micro Brow Pencil (Taupe)
Description / Features
- SUGAR’s Arch Arrival Micro Brow Pencil features an ultra-skinny micro-tip, allowing for precise, hair-like feathery strokes to fill and define brows with ease.
- This retractable eyebrow shaper has a smudge-proof, long-wear formula that ensures your brows stay on fleek throughout the day.
- Infused with a blend of nourishing jojoba oil and squalane, this 100% vegan brow pencil hydrates and soothes brow hairs, while the dual-ended design includes a handy spoolie for seamless brushing and blending.
4 – Blonde
This is a light yellow shade that has some golden tones in it. It is suitable for people with blonde or light red hair, and fair to medium skin tones. Blonde can also work for people with dark hair and fair skin, as long as they use a very light hand and blend well. Blonde can add some warmth and brightness to your brows, without making them too yellow or too orange. This is not common in India but is mostly available in the USA and other Western countries.
FEATURED
Revlon ColorStay Brow Pencil (Blonde)
Description / Features
- REVLON’s ColorStay Brow Pencil offers soft and blendable color, making it easy for anyone to define brows and achieve gorgeous arches.
- The automatic pencil features an angled tip for extra precision, allowing the creation of precise, hair-like strokes without the need for sharpening.
- With a 24-hour wear time, this eyebrow pencil has a waterproof formula that ensures it lasts without budging, and it comes in five beautiful, waterproof shades for versatile eyebrow makeup looks.
5 – Auburn
This is a reddish-brown shade that has some copper tones in it. It is perfect for people with red or auburn hair, and fair to medium skin tones. Auburn can also work for people with brown or black hair and fair skin, as long as they use a very light hand and blend well. Auburn can add some depth and dimension to your brows, without making them too red or too purple. This is not common in India but is mostly available in the USA and other Western countries.
FEATURED
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Micro Brow Pencil (Auburn)
Description / Features
- The NYX PROFESSIONAL micro mechanical brow pencil shapes, defines, and fills in sparse brows with a super-skinny tip, creating natural-looking, ultra-fine lines.
- Specializing in long-lasting wear, this brow pencil helps achieve a more defined look by filling in areas that may be sparse or over-tweezed.
- NYX PROFESSIONAL brow pencil is not tested on animals, and its natural material feature ensures a defined and natural finish for your brows.
6 – Gray
This is a dark gray shade that has some silver tones in it. It is ideal for people with gray or white hair, and fair to medium skin tones. Gray can also work for people with black hair and fair skin, as long as they use a light hand and blend well. Gray can create a sophisticated and elegant look for your brows, without making them too black or too blue.
FEATURED
Maybelline New York Fashion Brow Cream Pencil (Dark Gray)
Description / Features
- Maybelline New York New Fashion Brow Cream Pencil creates the most natural-looking brows with a super creamy and blendable formula.
- The improved formula ensures lasting brows for up to 12 hours, offering complete heatproof and waterproof impact to prevent smudging or sliding off.
- This brow pencil effectively fills, shapes, and defines your brows, providing good pay-off and an exclusive heat-proof feature for a flawless finish.
- Currently I use this product and it is highly recommended.
Conclusion
Choosing the right eyebrow pencil color for your brows can make a big difference in your appearance. It can enhance your natural beauty, define your expression, and complement your overall look. To choose the best eyebrow pencil color for you, you should consider your natural eyebrow color or hair color, your skin tone, and your skin undertone. You should also experiment with different shades and intensities until you find the one that suits you best. Remember, there is no one-size-fits-all solution when it comes to eyebrow pencil color. The most important thing is to find the color that makes you feel confident and beautiful!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
How do I know my skin’s undertone?
One way to find out your skin’s undertone is to look at the veins on your wrist. You have cold undertones if they seem blue or purple. But, you have warm undertones if they seem yellow or peach. You have neutral undertones if they seem neither blue nor yellow, or indistinct.
How do I apply eyebrow pencil?
To apply eyebrow pencil, start by brushing your brows with a spoolie brush to groom them. Then, use light strokes to fill in any sparse areas with the eyebrow pencil. Follow the natural shape of your brows and avoid drawing harsh lines. Finally, blend the product with the spoolie brush for a more natural finish.
How do I sharpen my eyebrow pencil?
To sharpen your eyebrow pencil, use a sharpener that is designed for makeup pencils. Make sure the sharpener is clean and sharp before using it. Twist the pencil gently in the sharpener until you get a fine point. Wipe off any excess product from the sharpener and the pencil with a tissue.
How do I choose the right eyebrow shape for my face?
To choose the right eyebrow shape for your face, you need to consider your face shape, your brow bone, and your personal preference. Generally, you want to choose an eyebrow shape that balances your face shape and enhances your features. For example, if you have a round face, you may want to choose a more arched eyebrow shape to add some definition. If you have a square face, you may want to choose a softer eyebrow shape to soften your angles.
How often should I trim my eyebrows?
The frequency of trimming your eyebrows depends on how fast your brows grow and how thick or thin you want them to be. Some people may need to trim their eyebrows every few weeks, while others may only need to trim them once in a while. To trim your eyebrows, use a pair of small scissors and a spoolie brush. Brush your brows upward with the spoolie brush and trim any hairs that are longer than the brow line. Then, brush your brows downward and trim any hairs that are longer than the brow line. Be careful not to over-trim or cut too close to the skin.
Question for you
- Which eyebrow pencil brand do you prefer for your brows and why?
Please feel free to share your answer in the comment box below.
Thank you for reading this blog post. I hope you found it informative and useful. I would love to hear your thoughts and opinions on this topic. Please leave a comment below and share your feedback, suggestions, questions, or anything else you want to say. I appreciate your support and engagement.
Author
Co-founder of Mom At Home Online, MBA (HR, Marketing), Blogger, Content Creator, Ex-Representative of Avon Beauty Products, Ex-Private Tutor, Experienced Music Teacher with 2 Diplomas, Trained Yoga Enthusiast, Movie Lover, and Traveler. Read more about us…
Last Modified Date:
